The hobbit the tolkien edit by tolkieneditor fanedit. Fan proves the hobbit only needed to be one movie after all many of the problems fans had with the movies are gone with some editing. Although i was not the first to create a hobbit fanedit, i was among the first four, and after three years of wide success, international interest, and a flood of comments, praise and constructive feedback, i have put together a final cut of the popular bilbo edition edit, a detailed revision of the three hobbit films into a single, succinct 4. There and back again, or the hobbit in 3 hours there. The hobbit movies all had a very the phantom menace kind of feel to me.
It is a reedit of the the hobbit trilogy into two films, as was originally the plan when production started. Click the title of the chapter for an indepth analysis of the booktofilm translation. The tolkien edit defy this rule by being based on material that is not commercially available to the public. Blackkklansmans topher grace made 2 hour the hobbit fan edit. I was a fan of the book as a child, and it was my first introduction to the amazing world of fantasy stories, but i swore id never step foot in a. Jan 20, 2015 i admit it, i havent seen the hobbit trilogy. The hobbit there and back again composite edition fanedit. Presenting a side quest film that acts as a companion piece to my main fanedit, j. Dec 23, 2018 an edit of the flashback battle of moria scene from an unexpected journey and desolation of smaug.
Jan 29, 2017 this edit is primarily sourced from the extended editions of all three films, however there are a few key edit points where what i wanted to do had essentially been done via the theatricals, so a few key transitions are taken from the theatrical versions once in the hall of the goblin king, beorns house, and the point at which the initial three armies meet avoiding the actual conflict. The changes made in my fan edit do not transfer those rights to me. Jul 31, 2018 while hardly the first fan edit of the hobbit, graces version may be one of the most palatable. It features many extended and deleted scenes, a restructured plot, and a visual overhaul. Watch the hobbit trilogy the way it was meant to be. Billy batson combined all three hobbit films into a single film that remained closer to the book. Apr 14, 2015 fan edits and projects for other properties. The plan is to edit three mediocre films into one hopefully excellent film. Topher grace says that he decided to make the hobbit trilogy edit after he came home from filming spike lees blackkklansman as a way to decompress. The hobbit recut the fan edits thread page 5 tolkien. Here you can find download links for the digital copy of the fan edit, dvdbluray iso files, along with custom disc and box art. The hobbit trilogy gets a 2hour fancut from topher grace.
Jan 20, 2015 the first hobbit trilogy fan edit is here, with a long list of huge improvements new, 57 comments by ben kuchera jan 20, 2015, 11. Middleearth saga by reediting the the hobbit films into the. This includes the removal of scenes or dialogue, replacement of audio andor visual elements, and adding material from sources such as deleted scenes or even other films. Tolkien superfan who goes by tolkieneditor has published a 4hour reedit or fan cut of the hobbit trilogy, with the conclusion still playing in theaters now. My edit seeks to strengthen the sense of finality in the film. A fan edit is a version of a film modified by a viewer, that removes, reorders, or adds material in order to create a new interpretation of the source material. Just in case a fourhour version of an eighthour trilogy was still too long for you, professional video editor david killstein has now gone and made an even more drastic cut of peter jacksons. The purist edit 2003, which was also based on a leaked dvd screener. Although i was not the first to create a hobbit fan edit, i was among the first four, and after three years of wide success, international interest, and a flood of comments, praise and constructive feedback, i have put together a final cut of the popular bilbo edition edit, a detailed revision of the three hobbit films into a single, succinct 4. Santa was busy over the holidays and so were our continue reading. Hobbit fanfiction archive with over 12,718 stories. The hobbit trilogy edited down to one movie by a fan.
Some of you may know that i had an attack of the clones edit in the works for quite a few years. A hobbits cut after the title of bilbo baggins own autobiographical book within the story. Jan 21, 2015 the hobbit fan edit takes you on an unextended journey. This edit is primarily sourced from the extended editions of all three films, however there are a few key edit points where what i wanted to do had essentially been done via the theatricals, so a few key transitions are taken from the theatrical versions once in the hall of the goblin king, beorns house, and the point at which the initial three armies meet avoiding the actual conflict. The hobbit fanedit takes you on an unextended journey. The hobbit fanedit takes you on an unextended journey cnet. One new fanedit for yall this week, burning out its continue reading week of january 5, 2019 new fanedit. There and back again a hobbits cut the hobbit in 3.
Tolkiens the hobbit by dustin lee, and, judging by the fact that some of your qualifiers are most professional and most enjoyable, i think that you may agree with me. This is reminiscent of the first fan edit of the lord of the rings film series, the two towers. The hobbit was somehow filmed as a trilogy aka the hobbit. Aug 14, 2016 many of you probably saw or heard of the tolkien edit when it was released in early 2015. My goal is to make very minimal changes to most of tlj, using hal9000s legendary edition of the film as a base. I feel this version, however, is superior to most of the other fanedits of the hobbit i have personally watched. The combined runtime of all three films was nearly 9 hours, of which 5 hours was cut. It was hastily assembled and had very poor audiovisual quality, especially since the editor used a pirated dvd screener copy of battle of five armies as his source. One new hobbit fan edit has shorn the series of hours of footage, leaving a roughly fourhour story that omits many of jacksons inventions and digressions in an attempt to get closer to the. Jrr tolkiens the hobbit a fanedit by dustin lee posts.
This keeps this fan edit distinct from others in a way that i. If youre a fan of the hobbit, then billy batsons the hobbit is not to be missed. I made this to try to recreate the battle without any scenes or narration interrupting it so. Apr 14, 2018 although i was not the first to create a hobbit fan edit, i was among the first four, and after three years of wide success, international interest, and a flood of comments, praise and constructive feedback, i have put together a final cut of the popular bilbo edition edit, a detailed revision of the three hobbit films into a single, succinct 4. Im thinking about watching a fan edit version of the hobbit, these two seem to be the most promising, but i cant decide which to download. One widely circulated fan edit in 2015, the tolkien edit, ran four hours long. I found it was the perfect length for a hobbit fan edit and paced itself rather well. Despite my dislike of the theatrical releases however, i still held out some hope that they all. The first hobbit trilogy fan edit is here, with a long list of huge improvements new, 57 comments by ben kuchera jan 20, 2015, 11. Many of you probably saw or heard of the tolkien edit when it was released in early 2015. This page is dedicated to my ongoing fanedit project for the hobbit trilogy, titled j.
Personally, i enjoyed all three movies, but i would love. Ive spent many weeks carefully recrafting the work into what im calling there and back again. There and back again a hobbits cut the hobbit in 3 hours. This channel is dedicated to my ongoing fanedit project for the hobbit trilogy, titled j. The story of the hobbit didnt need to be stretched out to fill three featurelength films, but thats what the studio decided to do.
Want to watch the hobbit trilogy but think peter jacksons fanfic is way too long. While hardly the first fan edit of the hobbit, graces version may be one of the most palatable. View, comment, download and edit hobbit minecraft skins. A fan has created their own 4hour reedit of the hobbit. Jobilt has been working on three fan edit versions of trilogy, coming up with her preferred edition 2 hours and 42 minutes, an. I have recently completed a fan edit of the last jedi that seeks to make the film work as a conclusion to the skywalker saga.
Cyborg city in my previous post, i wrote about the anticipation for fan edits of the hobbit trilogy as a single film and i characterized them as inevitable edits. Fanedits are posted by the faneditor and takes no responsibility for their availability. Jobilt has been working on three fanedit versions of trilogy, coming up with her preferred edition 2 hours and 42 minutes, an. Collection of hobbit trilogy fanedits and adaptations. While we dont host fanedits themselves, we do store dlc, nzb and torrent files for users to easily download edits from other sources. Direct download links available for the main fan edit and durins folk. The changes made in my fanedit do not transfer those rights to me.
That said, i do still prefer the maple films fan edit, it just feels a lot richer in terms of character, and its use of extended edition scenes make for a well rounded viewing experience. Tolkiens the hobbit is officially listed on the internet fan edit database. Yes, perhaps it makes me elitist or anal, but it is how i feel about it. The tolkien edit, which is the first of these recombinations to be publicly released. For those of you unfamiliar with the site, is a great resource and database for all types of alternate versions of your favorite movies and tv shows. This is the main database collection for fan edits online. This fan edit cuts it down to a much more manageable. Jrr tolkiens the hobbit a fanedit by dustin lee home.
This keeps this fan edit distinct from others in a way that i think is respectful to tolkiens own intentions. Tolkiens the hobbit a fan edit by dustin lee on vimeo. An edit of the flashback battle of moria scene from an unexpected journey and desolation of smaug. The hobbit fan edit cuts the whole epic down to four.
1219 1101 823 978 1625 914 967 1014 629 1239 1397 1063 1357 75 224 1204 1582 417 388 625 1630 861 522 153 602 1293 324 282 47 31